The Boat That Rocked review

Maybe Richard Curtis’ insistence on directing has got in the way of his writing (which we know he is more than capable of; Blackadder, Four Weddings, even Notting Hill was passable) but you have to blame both for such a ramshackle film with terrible pacing that sees numerous set pieces (such as the ending, for Christ’s sake) appear as if by magic, with absolutely no build-up.

The script is lightweight and cheap, raising a serious concern that Curtis has totally lost it (naming a character “Twatt” is a pale imitation of naming a character “Darling”) whereas the cast is both a saving grace and another millstone. Those that are good are terrifically underused, largely because the film suffers from (one of) the same problem(s) Love Actually had; far too many big actors playing one-dimensional characters with big personalities so that in the end it’s nearly impossible to focus on, let alone care about, the plight of any of them.

This is an over-long, lazy, unchallenging film devoid of substance, intelligence, and the level of laughs we should expect from such a heavyweight comedy production.

1 out of 5

1st Apr 2009

Leave a comment

TA Wittering

  • Carnage review: A nicely adapted play, progressing like a fine stand-up routine, complete with substantial laughs.

    6 Feb 2012, 1:08 pm

  • Young Adult is showing on criminally few screens in London. Made the pilgrimage to @ritzycinema to see it. What a great venue.

    4 Feb 2012, 12:36 pm

  • Some top-drawer films recently released: Carnage, The Descendants, Like Crazy, Young Adult, Martha Marcy May Marlene are all 4/5

    4 Feb 2012, 12:34 pm

  • Chronicle review: Not entirely convincing but a nice anti-super-hero concept with a thrilling finale.

    3 Feb 2012, 1:56 pm

  • A tad late to the game (behind 5 million-ish people) but I found the present-day Ferris Bueller to be quite chucklesome t.co/KkI0pxVw

    1 Feb 2012, 9:55 am

Follow Talking Animal on Twitter